Katie Thomas helped one young accounting firm grow from about $150,000 a year to a seven-figure practice. The firm didn’t chase individual clients one by one. It went to the business coach who already served its niche. Katie is a CPA and the CEO and founder of Leaders Online, a marketing firm that helps accounting firms increase their impact, influence, and income. She works with CPA firm owners to build intentional client acquisition systems around a clearly defined ideal client.
In this episode of The Accountant’s Flight Plan, Brannon Poe and Katie start with capacity. Many CPA firms charge legacy prices to legacy clients, which leaves them at capacity and underpaid. Katie has never seen a firm end up worse off after raising prices. Fewer clients leave than owners expect, and the ones who stay pay a fair price for the work.
From there, the conversation moves to referrals, ideal client definition, and partner alignment. Referrals remain valuable, but they tend to bring more of the same. Katie explains how to tell referral partners where the firm is headed. She also covers how to rework a CPA firm website so prospects are 90% sure of the fit before the first call. Brannon connects the topic to firm succession. Buyers look for low owner hours, healthy cash flow, and steady growth, and a repeatable marketing system supports all three. For more on what drives accounting practice value, see the Poe Group Advisors valuation report.
The Conversation Covers:
- How raising legacy prices creates capacity without the client losses most firm owners expect
- Why referral partners need to hear where your accounting practice is headed
- How to define an ideal client using profitability, problems solved, and market access
- Why partner alignment matters before a CPA firm changes its marketing message
- How a website that answers pricing questions prepares prospects before the first call
- Why a repeatable client acquisition system raises firm value at the time of sale
Katie’s biggest lesson is that focused marketing reaches people more effectively than broad marketing. As she puts it, boil a pot of water before you try to boil the ocean.
This Episode Is For firm owners curious about attracting more ideal clients, partners ready to align on a shared growth vision, and practitioners wondering how marketing can support capacity, recruiting, and long-term firm value.
How can a CPA firm at capacity create room to grow?
A CPA firm at capacity can create room to grow by reviewing and raising legacy prices that no longer reflect its work and expertise. Katie Thomas, CPA and founder of Leaders Online, has never seen a firm end up worse off after raising prices. Some clients may leave, which opens capacity, and the clients who stay pay appropriately for the work. Brannon Poe, founder of Poe Group Advisors, adds that Accounting Practice Academy members find clients rarely leave in the numbers they expect.
Should a CPA firm rely on referrals to grow?
Referrals are valuable, but on their own they tend to bring more of the same clients. Katie Thomas, CPA, recommends that accounting firms define who they want to serve and which services they want to offer, then share that direction with referral partners. With that clarity, partners can send clients who better match where the firm is headed.
How should a CPA firm define its ideal client?
A CPA firm can define its ideal client by studying the clients it already enjoys serving. Katie Thomas, CPA, suggests looking at the problems the firm likes to solve for them, which clients are most profitable, how the relationships are structured, how often the firm communicates with them, and how easy it is to reach more people like them. In firms with multiple partners, everyone needs to align on the definition, since each partner has a different book of business. A clear ideal client profile still leaves room to accept good clients who don’t match it exactly.
How does marketing affect the value of a CPA firm when it’s time to sell?
Marketing can increase a CPA firm’s value by supporting steady growth, lower owner hours, and strong cash flow to the owner. Brannon Poe, founder of Poe Group Advisors, notes that buyers look closely at growth rate: a slightly flat rate can be acceptable, but declines hurt value. Katie Thomas, CPA, adds that a firm brand and a repeatable system for attracting clients prepare a practice for a new owner to step in. A steady flow of new leads also helps a firm stay selective and protect its margins.
What should a CPA firm website include to attract ideal clients?
A CPA firm website should speak directly to its ideal client instead of listing services like a brochure. Katie Thomas, CPA, recommends testimonials from clients in similar situations and answers to common questions, such as when to hire a firm and what pricing typically looks like. A firm doesn’t need to list exact prices: a starting package price or a typical client average works. The goal is for prospects to be about 90% sure of the fit before the first call.
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 – Welcome and guest introduction: Katie Thomas, CPA and CEO of Leaders Online
01:37 – Why CPA firms at capacity stay stuck, and what raising prices on legacy clients changes
04:56 – Why referral-based firms keep attracting the same clients
07:10 – Getting partners aligned on an ideal client
09:02 – Defining the ideal client: services, profitability, behaviors, and market access
10:57 – Will naming an ideal client exclude too many people? No, it will help you better find the right people
12:38 – What a CPA firm website should say to attract ideal clients
14:53 – Where to find ideal clients: conferences, social media, and podcasts
15:40 – Find where your clients are: how a firm went from $150,000 to seven figures
18:01 – Why a firm brand and repeatable system matter when it is time to sell
19:50 – How growth and margins affect CPA firm valuation
21:48 – How marketing helps accounting firms attract top talent
24:02 – Katie’s story: leaving a Big Four firm to start Leaders Online
25:41 – Book recommendations: “How to Win Friends and Influence People,” “Start with Why,” and “Who Not How”
BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS & REFERENCES:
How to Win Friends and Influence People by Dale Carnegie
Start with Why by Simon Sinek
Who Not How by Dan Sullivan and Benjamin Hardy
Poe Group Valuation Report: https://poegroupadvisors.com/value/
TRANSCRIPT
Brannon: I’m Brannon Poe, and this is The Accountant’s Flight Plan podcast, where you can enjoy engaging conversations about mergers and acquisitions and accounting practice management. Listen in on strategies to build a more fun and valuable accounting firm.
Welcome to The Accountant’s Flight Plan podcast. I have a special guest today who is another CPA, Katie Thomas. Let me introduce her briefly. I hear a lot about firms being at capacity, and I think most firms that are growing find themselves in that situation sooner or later. A lot of firms are built through referrals, and referrals tend to bring more of the same clients instead of maybe your ideal client. Katie has built her career around solving that problem.
She’s a CPA and the CEO and founder of Leaders Online, a marketing firm that helps accounting firms increase their impact, influence, and income. She brings something unique to accounting marketing: because she’s a CPA, she speaks the language. She has been recognized as a CPA Practice Advisor 40 Under 40 honoree and a Top 50 Women in Accounting recipient. Congratulations on that. We’re going to talk today about how CPA firms can build an intentional client acquisition system and why that system makes the practice more scalable and valuable. Katie, welcome to the show.
Katie: Thanks so much, Brannon, for having me. I’m excited to be here.
Brannon: Let’s talk about capacity first. I hear it all the time. People say, I could grow if I had more capacity, but they also might not be pruning clients who aren’t a good fit. What’s your take on the cost of that to a CPA firm over time?
Katie: I have this conversation a lot. I was just talking to a CPA firm and seven of their leaders two days ago about this exact situation. They said, we know the type of client we ultimately want, but right now we’re at capacity. When it came to letting some of these clients go and creating more capacity, they were nervous. What are we going to do if staff are idle? Or even with existing clients, what if we raise our price today? What’s going to happen? Often we jump to the worst-case scenario.
So let’s take one situation. Let’s say we raise some of our prices, and we assume a lot of clients are going to balk, which in reality is often not the case. But even if some do, I’ve never seen a case where you aren’t in a better situation after raising your price. Some might naturally leave, but at the end of the day, you now have a little bit of capacity, and you’re being paid appropriately for the work you’re doing. A lot of times, as I’m sure you see, firms are charging legacy prices for legacy clients, and that doesn’t accurately reflect the work they do today or the expertise they have. They trap themselves, because they aren’t charging enough, they’re at capacity, and they’re stuck. Until you make a change, it’s very difficult to have anything change.
What’s the definition of insanity? Doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result. It might not be easy to have these conversations, but that doesn’t mean they’re not worth having.
Brannon: This tracks really well with our Accounting Practice Academy and what we see with our members. A lot of times I see practices that are very unfocused. They’re trying to cover a wide variety of services, and it’s too much for the size team they have, so you have to create capacity before you can really make things better in the firm. On pricing, our members have found time and time again that they think they’re going to go up on price to create capacity, but clients don’t leave in the numbers they expect.
Katie: Right. We always assume the worst.
Brannon: Yes. Let’s talk about referrals. I get a lot of people who say, we don’t do any marketing, I’m proud of that, we get all of our business through referrals. How does that prevent you from building the type of firm you want?
Katie: I would never tell a firm to stop taking referrals, because they’re valuable. It’s often how a firm has grown. But you need to be intentional about those referrals, and that starts with being clear about who you want to serve, what services you want to offer them, and how you want those services to look when you’re working with your clients. Once you’ve nailed that down, you can go to your referral partners and say, here’s where we’re headed. This is who we want to best serve, and this is what it will look like when our future clients work with us.
You’re not saying that you’re no longer working with all the clients they sent before. Maybe you aren’t, but that’s not the message. You’re just saying, here’s our plan moving forward, and now everyone’s on the same page. If you leave it status quo, birds of a feather flock together, and you’ll probably just keep getting the same thing and perpetuating the cycle. You may be keeping up with the top-line growth you want, or whatever your traditional trajectory has been. Maybe it has flatlined, maybe it has grown some. But meeting the pace you expect doesn’t mean it’s fulfilling you with the work you want. At some point it’s up to you as a firm partner, leader, or executive to say, this is where we want to go, and let’s educate the people who send us clients so they can better align with that future vision.
Brannon: What I’ve experienced is that it takes that intentionality to, for one, know who your ideal client is. I think a lot of firms don’t have a great definition of who they want to serve. Do you find, as someone doing marketing, that getting a firm to define and be clear about who they want to serve and how is the biggest lift?
Katie: It’s a big one. A lot of times that is the leading problem, but when you start digging into it, especially if the firm has multiple partners, there are other issues around it, like what’s in it for me? Here’s an example. You start digging in and it’s, we want service-based businesses doing $1 million or $2 million up to $10 or $15 million, with a few employees. But then different partners have different books of business. One might say, I’m really heavy on individual tax, so if the firm only targets these business owners, what does that mean for me? Or another might say, I really work with private foundations, so what does this language mean for my book of business? We have to get clear, but we also need to get everyone rowing in the same direction, so that the organizational goals also fulfill the personal goals of the people who are part of that organization.
Brannon: Partner alignment is key in a lot of areas. I never thought about marketing being something you need partner alignment on, but it makes total sense when you say it. So how should a firm owner or partners identify the clients they want more of when building a client acquisition system?
Katie: Start by looking at who the clients are that you like to serve now. What problems do you like helping them solve? What is profitable for your firm? How are those relationships structured? How often are you communicating with them? What are the behaviors of those people? And then market access: how easy is it to reach those people?
As you build out this ideal client, this is who we want to market to and find more of. But that doesn’t mean that just because we have this gold standard, if an A-tier client doesn’t come in tomorrow and a B-tier client does and checks the boxes that make them acceptable, we have to turn that client away. That’s what I always encourage people to do: don’t get so hung up on what you could accept. If you’re going out to intentionally attract who you want, create that gold standard so people can naturally say, yes, that’s me, or no, that’s not me. You’ll still have plenty of B-tier clients if you want them. I’m a CPA, and I have not touched a tax return in almost a decade, and I still get inquiries. Hey, can you do my taxes? Hey, do you do accounting for decent-sized business owners? I’m confident you’ll still get plenty of inquiries too, but this allows you to focus on finding the right ones you’re putting intention toward.
Brannon: Is there a concern that if we put this message out into the world about who we’re looking for, we’re going to exclude too many people? Is that what you deal with a lot?
Katie: 100%. It’s a mindset thing. I don’t want to be woo-woo here, but it really is. If you do the research on the number of business owners doing a million plus who have the characteristics you’re looking for, there’s plenty of opportunity out there, and it’s impossible for you to reach everyone on a mass scale. That’s the other important thing about marketing: it takes very focused effort to reach people, and you can do that effectively when the group is narrow enough. When it’s too wide, it’s very hard to reach people. If you try to go after a huge central market, you’re trying to boil the ocean. Let’s try to boil a pot of water first, and you can always expand over time.
Brannon: A lot of our clients have specialized in a niche, and the ones that have found plenty of opportunity have typically grown faster than more generalist firms for that very reason. They’ve narrowly defined who they’re going after, they can tailor the message to that ideal client target, and it just works.
Katie: It just works.
Brannon: So how should a CPA firm’s website and marketing assets change to attract those ideal clients?
Katie: The whole goal of marketing is for the right people to find you and say, yes, this is for me, or no, this is not for me. When you put that lens on it, a lot of things change by just a little bit. Your home page looks a little different in who it speaks to. Your services page looks different. You have testimonials showing proof: here’s someone in your spot, and here’s the result we got them. You also look at the common questions they have, like, at what stage in my business should I work with you? What does pricing look like? That doesn’t mean you need to say exactly what a service will cost. It could be, most of our clients average this, or all of our packages start at this per month. It’s answering all those questions before someone talks to you, so they feel confident you’re a good option and, by the time they’re on the phone, they’re 90% sure you’re a good fit.
A lot of CPA firm websites are just a brochure. It’s a bunch of services, but it doesn’t call out anyone in particular. It doesn’t say, I know the problems you’re facing, I know where you want to go, and here’s an example, not just of services, but of a person we’ve helped like you, and another person we’ve helped like you. That’s really the goal: not just for someone to find the website, but to say, yes, that is absolutely for me.
Brannon: Once those assets are changed, how does a firm generate consistent demand among the right audience and convert it into good conversations and new clients? How does the conversion piece work?
Katie: Once a firm knows who the ideal target is, it’s time to ask, where are they spending their time that I can consistently spend my time too? That could look like going to their industry conferences, spending time on a social media channel where they also spend time, or getting on podcasts they listen to. Often you want to pick multiple channels: where are they that you can also be? And I really encourage firms to think bigger than going one by one.
Here’s an example. When we first started working with this firm, they were pretty new, doing maybe $150,000 a year. They started working with fitness coaches. Rather than going one by one to online personal trainers, they went to a business coach for fitness coaches, and they quickly became a seven-figure firm. They weren’t trying to go one by one. They asked, who are the fitness coaches who own businesses, and who are they going to for business advice? Think about where your people are hanging out, the groups and communities they’re part of, and how you can plug into those places.
Brannon: I can see how having these systems in place would scale, and it’s less dependent on the owner’s personal network. When we sell firms, one of the things buyers are really looking for is fairly low owner hours and good cash flow to the owner. I find a lot of CPAs aren’t naturally attracted to marketing when they’re past the startup phase, which I feel is a mistake. You should always be growing, and if you want your role to change, you have to grow your business. Can you talk about the long-term benefits to a firm, valuation benefits, anything that comes to mind? When people really need new business, like a startup, they’re willing to implement these things, but more mature firms are sometimes less inclined.
Katie: That’s very true. When you’re new, you’re making decisions for the first time. You don’t have a bunch of clients you’re concerned about impacting capacity with your staff, so in a way it’s easier to make these decisions at the beginning. But long term, if you’re looking to sell your business, you’re building a huge asset, and someone has to be able to come in and ask, once you leave, what does the future of this business look like?
Let’s be honest: as an accountant, you’re in the business of serving people. It’s a relationship-based business. But that doesn’t mean you can’t have a brand for the firm and systems in place to constantly attract your ideal client, even if you’re no longer with the firm. Think about the real estate CPA and Brandon Hall. He built a strong online brand. They serve a lot of real estate investors, but he’s no longer the face of it. He stepped out, because he built a brand for his firm in this industry, this vertical, this niche, where people know that if they’re a real estate investor looking for an accountant, they go to the real estate CPA. It wasn’t always that way. He was the face of it for a while, but like I said, he built a brand over time, and someone else could come in and buy that business, and because the firm has a repeatable system to attract clients, a brand, and a name in the marketplace, it’s still going to do that. I shouldn’t say no matter who comes in. They have to keep those systems in place. But it is prepared for someone else to step in.
Brannon: One thing buyers do look at is growth. They look at the growth rate of a business, and it’s okay if it’s a little flat, but you definitely don’t want to see declines when you go to sell your business.
Katie: And I think new leads are a way to continually grow the firm and also protect its margins. People don’t realize that the more incoming you have, the more selective and curated you can be. I just see that firms that are growing also tend to protect their margins, if they’re growing intentionally.
Brannon: Yes.
Katie: Do you have a valuation number for people listening? I’m not in the business of selling firms, but if a firm grows 10% every year versus 5%, or maybe 20% versus 5%, how does that growth rate impact valuation?
Brannon: I don’t have a formula people could simply calculate. However, we do have a valuation report that’s really comprehensive and discusses all of the major factors that influence valuation, growth being one of them. We’ll share that in the show notes for people listening.
I’m a big believer in what you’re talking about with marketing. I do think capacity is a big issue, but in some ways I’m starting to see the industry ease up a little bit. I think there’s a little more talent available to owners than there was two years ago, so hopefully that continues to get better. And I’m glad you talked about capacity, because marketing also helps you attract top talent.
Katie: Yes.
Brannon: The people who are your A players, the ones you want on your team, want a firm that’s growing, with a clear vision, a clear place in a market that’s growing and expanding, and growth systems in place. So don’t discount what you’re doing to attract clients. It’s also going to help you attract talent and help with that capacity.
Katie: Yes.
Brannon: Are you seeing a lot of websites that are expressing more about their culture, built with that in mind?
Katie: We do. What’s interesting is that about three years ago, and we’re not recruiters at all, we added a part of our marketing program just for helping firms attract talent. A lot of it is about leveraging one of the partners’ profiles on social media. We have engagements with firms, some going on for years now, where that’s our only focus. It has helped them a lot with capacity and getting really great talent, and while we’re focused on the partner sharing stories about the culture, what it’s like to work at the firm, and creating connections with potential new hires, their clients notice it too, so they go hand in hand. When you think about marketing, it’s just growth. Whether you’re growing from new clients or from adding top team members, it all feeds into growth.
Brannon: Love that. I’m going to turn to a couple of closing questions. One question we’ve been asking guests is about a memorable story. It could be funny, or just something that stands out because it was interesting in some way. Do you have a story you could share?
Katie: I could share a lot of stories when I think back on my journey running Leaders Online. When I left my job at one of the Big Four and said I was going to start a business, they asked, what’s your plan? What are you going to do, just hang a shingle? I said, I just might, I’m going to figure it out. Then I saw that person about a year ago, and he said, I guess you figured it out. I guess it worked.
So for anyone listening who’s wondering, should I start marketing, or should I take Brannon’s advice and really nail down this ideal client, don’t hesitate to try something new. If anyone has put thoughts in your head that it won’t work, find new people to follow who put thoughts in your head that it will work, because there are plenty of people out there making things work that you want to do. They’re just doing the thing you need to do.
Brannon: I like your response: I just might. Hang a shingle. Last question: do you have a book recommendation?
Katie: Two books. Probably ones you’ve heard of, but if you haven’t read them, I highly recommend them. “How to Win Friends and Influence People” is a phenomenal book about building trust and relationships with people. And “Start with Why” by Simon Sinek is great if you haven’t read it. If you’re thinking about how you want to position yourself, it will bring a lot of clarity, because it helps you figure out why you do what you do on a deeper level. I really recommend both of those.
Brannon: Those are good. I think the first one was originally written in the 40s, or it’s a classic, 1936.
Katie: It’s an old one, but it’s timeless.
Brannon: Timeless.
Katie: What’s your favorite book?
Brannon: Oh, gosh. I followed Dan Sullivan, the founder of Strategic Coach, and he has a couple of really good ones. The idea is that our instinct, when there’s a problem, is to think, how do I fix this? His book, “Who Not How,” says the first question to start asking is, who can help me fix this? You get progress much, much faster.
Katie: I’m going to add that to my list. I’ve had that recommended to me before, so I’m going to read it.
Brannon: It’s a good one. All right, one more question and then we’ll wrap it up. What’s the best way for people to find you or follow you online?
Katie: I’m Katie Thomas, CPA on all social media platforms. I’m most active on LinkedIn. If you want to get in touch, go to leaders-online.com.
Brannon: Love it. Katie, thank you so much.
Katie: Thanks so much for having me, Brannon. Fun to chat.




